Alcoholics anonymous has two million members worldwide. Alcoholics anonymous aa is an international mutual aid fellowship with the stated purpose of enabling its members to stay sober and help other alcoholics achieve sobriety. Cain a useful idea has turned into a religious movementand a hindrance to research, psychiatry, and to many alcoholics who need a. Alcoholics anonymous is probably without serious side. Aug 06, 2007 joe rogans life advice will change your life must watch joe rogan motivation duration. There is no doubt that alcoholics anonymous has helped some alcoholics but not as many as you may have been led to believe turn their lives around. Mar 12, 2014 by chaz bufe, author of alcoholics anonymous. Cult or cure with a description of a standard aa meetingdominated by a few people who tell their same, selfserving stories for the umpteenth time, the proceedings unfocussed and unhelpful, the. The published works on effective treatments for alcoholism is brie. Aa is nonprofessional, selfsupporting, and apolitical. Paperback january 1, 1998 by charles bufe author visit amazons charles bufe page.
It is not a cult, but a program that has saved millions of lives since its inception people are mandated by the courts at times, because it works. Many of us have been misled by the religion that claims not to be a religion. The meetings secretary and the evenings speaker are already seated at the table, smoking cigarettes and slurping coffee. The success rates of alcoholics anonymous are hard to come by, primarily because the program is supposed to be anonymous hence the title. Its only membership requirement is a desire to stop drinking. One example is from chaz bufe, who listed seventeen criteria in his book alcoholics anonymous. It questions the methods used by alcoholics anonymous such as the steps, and shows how aa grew from a fundamentalist religious organisation called the oxford group. Alcoholics anonymous should not be a cult for the retardation of the arrested alcoholic. To back their claims, they cite anecdotal evidence and uncontrolled studies. I n the last few years, the movement to challenge alcoholics anonymous aa the organization that has long been the standardbearer in the fight to combat alcohol addiction has intensified. I just cannot think of any other cult or organization that has more slogans. This opening vignette conveys a lot of informationit tells you that chaz bufe has been there. Alcoholics anonymous cult aa resembles a religious cult as a group which does not tolerate any kind of individuality or freedom of thought, aa exhibits characteristics of religious affiliations which have been called cults because of the emotional and cognitive harm they do to their members. For our group purpose there is but one ultimate authoritya loving god as he may express himself in our group conscience.
Silkworths belladonna cure, a treatment regimen which included morphine and other psychoactive drugs in addition to belladonna which in large doses is a powerful hallucinogen. I recently read the sober truth which is an excellent book by lance dodes. Alcoholics anonymous is a worldwide fellowship that focuses on promoting itself to those who struggle with alcoholism. Alcoholics anonymous cult is alcoholics anonymous a beneficial and effective support group for alcoholism, or is there something more sinister going on. Dec 31, 2017 alcoholics anonymous counterfeit steps of aa written by brenda lane in simple terms the following steps are the fake aa that is commonly believed and professed by those who have not actually read the literature. Our leaders are but trusted servants, they do not govern. The book is meant to show others how they recovered. An elderly lady in a prim white blouse has just delivered the bad news, with deep. Some of us suffered for years oblivious to the fact that aa offers no reliable or even sincere method to help alcohol troubled people to recover from addiction.
Carson cant keep up with rodney dangerfields nonstop oneliners 1974 duration. Alcoholics anonymous counterfeit steps of aa written by brenda lane in simple terms the following steps are the fake aa that is commonly believed and professed by those who have not actually read the literature. Cultspeak, groupthink, suppression of dissent, and enforced conformity in thinking. Jul 05, 2017 the success rates of alcoholics anonymous are hard to come by, primarily because the program is supposed to be anonymous hence the title. To anyone who is having trouble with alcohol i say. Sep 20, 2019 another challenge is to read this book aa. An elderly lady in a prim white blouse has just delivered the bad news, with deep apologies. But there are also so many active factors that affect addiction and recovery, such as relapse, level of function, and resulting illnesses. Mar 20, 2009 still, it interesting to see what the experts think. Alcoholics anonymous appears equal to or superior to conventional treatments for alcoholism, and the skepticism of some professionals regarding aa as a first rank treatment for alcoholism would appear. Finally, frank, reminds us that in group therapy healing came from caring for each other, not oneself.
Is alcoholics anonymous really a harmful religious cult. Alcoholics anonymous cult aa resembles a religious cult as a group which does not tolerate any kind of individuality or freedom of thought, aa exhibits characteristics of religious affiliations which have been called cults because of the emotional and. Alcoholics anonymous aa is an informal meeting society for recovering alcoholics whose primary purpose is to stay sober and help other alcoholics achieve sobriety. Denigration of competing sects, cults, religions, personal attacks on critics. Prediction of controlled drinking by alcoholics and problem drinkers.
Ursula kenny talks to the disaffected who have rejected its road to recovery. The antiaa book that saved my butt after reading ken ragges the real aa behind the myth of 12 step. Alcoholics anonymous by charles bufe overdrive rakuten. Read download alcoholics anonymous pdf pdf download. Written by an awardwinning psychiatrist and educator in the treatment of alcohol and drug abuse, what is alcoholics anonymous. On that day he was readmitted to towns hospital, sedated, and subjected to dr. Joe rogans life advice will change your life must watch joe rogan motivation duration. Alcoholics anonymous is not effective sharp and pointed. Cult or cure with a description of a standard aa meetingdominated by a few people who tell their same, selfserving stories for the umpteenth time, the proceedings unfocussed and unhelpful, the environment filled with smoke and other unhealthy environmental contaminantsfrom which most people leave with basic psychological and social needs unmet. This well researched, painstakingly documented book provides detailed information on the rightwing evangelical organization oxford group movement that gave birth.
Cult or cure aas supporters commonly trumpet aa as the best, if not the only, way to deal with alcohol problems. Bufe concluded that aa is not a cult, though it does have dangerous cultlike tendencies. The full text of this article hosted at is unavailable due to technical difficulties. Alcoholics anonymous appears equal to or superior to conventional treatments for alcoholism, and the skepticism of some professionals regarding aa as a first rank treatment for alcoholism would appear to be unwarranted. Adults n 1,726 participating in a randomized controlled trial of psychosocial treatments for alcohol use disorder project match were assessed at treatment intake, and 3, 6, 9, 12, and 15 months on their aa attendance, spiritualreligious practices, and alcohol use outcomes using validated measures. To discuss the mechanism of action, the efficacy and the safety of alcoholics anonymous aa in the treatment of alcoholism. Criticism of aa or alcoholics anonymous is nothing new. Unquestionable dogma, sacred science, and infallible ideology. The relationship of alcoholics anonymous to the professional community is an extremely important and longstanding one. Free full pdf downlaod alcoholics anonymous cult or cure full ebook online free. If youre familiar with the world of addiction recovery, then youre no doubt acquainted with alcoholics anonymousor aa as it is more commonly known. Cult or cure with a description of a standard aa meetingdominated by a few people who tell their same, selfserving stories for the umpteenth time, the proceedings unfocussed and. Cain a useful idea has turned into a religious movementand a hindrance to research, psychiatry, and to many alcoholics who need a different kind of help.
Article tools add to favorites email to a friend download citation track citations. This well researched, painstakingly documented book provides detailed information on the rightwing evangelical organization oxford group movement that gave birth to aa. One thing for certain about the human racewe get some kind of fulfillment out of stamping a bad label on groups of people, organizations, types of people etc. Introduction by stanton peele this well researched, painstakingly documented book provides detailed information on the rightwing evangelical organization oxford group movement that gave birth to aa.
Bufe concluded that aa is not a cult, though it does have dangerous cult like tendencies. See sharp press, 1998 introduction to charles bufes aa. Free shipping get free shipping free 58 day shipping within the u. Free books and book excerpts including the complete the real aa and alcoholics anonymous. The program is more spiritual than most churches and operates on self examination and responsibility. The aa program of recovery is set forth in the twelve steps aa was founded in. The church will be closed tomorrow, and the drunks are freaking out. Objective to discuss the mechanism of action, the efficacy and the safety of alcoholics anonymous aa in the treatment of alcoholism. Other people, mostly casually dressed men in the 30s and 40s, are filing in, gradually filling the seats, and gradually filling the air with tobacco smoke.
As a recovering catholic, i urge every roman catholic to read this book. And if youve had more than two or three aarelated conversations, its highly likely that someone compared aa to a cult in at least one of those discussions. Cult speak, groupthink, suppression of dissent, and enforced conformity in thinking. Pdf adobe drm can be read on any device that can open pdf adobe drm files. There are several sets of criteria for what a cult is, with each having similar components. Nov 04, 2015 i n the last few years, the movement to challenge alcoholics anonymous aa the organization that has long been the standardbearer in the fight to combat alcohol addiction has intensified. In addition, aa serendipitously follows the principles of cognitive behaviour therapy in relapse prevention.
Alcoholics anonymous has to be the worlds champion for slogans. Aug, 2007 carson cant keep up with rodney dangerfields nonstop oneliners 1974 duration. Aa suggests that alcoholics follow its program and abstain from alcohol in order to recover from alcoholism, and share their experience, strength, and hope with each other that they may solve their common. Alcoholics anonymous counterfeit steps of aa recovery. Neither ragge nor bufe seems to have been aware of a very pertinent article written in 1984 by two astute californians, francesca alexander and michele rollins. Still, it interesting to see what the experts think. Alcoholics anonymous meetings, after all, are theonlyplacesintheworldthataredenselypopulatedby alcoholics with stable sobriety.
5 1072 1369 1213 267 1333 797 117 1298 115 317 1350 1079 228 1349 418 268 527 561 248 1122 121 1489 1372 689 490 1440 305 286 356 535 419 553 1365 1315 1145 312 1352 1390